Which Water Filter Should You Use for Backpacking?

5 Comments

1. None of these filter viruses btw, so you can still get sick from farmland run-off or other unexpected upstream polluters.

   Reply

2. I love the BeFree, but damn it clogs so often. I’ve cleaned and cleaned but damn.

   Reply

3. Stay away from platypus they do not stand behind their product.

   Reply

4. UK bog water in areas like Dartmoor, Exmoor, the Peak District, as well as Irish bog water areas, and the Scottish Highlands presents two brutal challenges for water filters: fine micro-peat silt and sticky organic tannins (which turn the water into dark tea).Here is why three of these struggle in UK bogs and why the MSR MiniWorks EX comes out on top: 1. Why the MSR Guardian Fails Hollow Fiber Nightmare: Uses ultra-fine hollow fiber (0.02 micron)) designed to physically block viruses. However, fine peat particles and sticky tannins blind hollow fibers quickly. Not Field-Scrubbable: Even with its self-flushing mechanism, sticky peat silt and tannins bond to delicate internal fibers. Once choked, you cannot scrub hollow fibers without destroying them. No Carbon Filter: Lacks an activated carbon core. Even if it purifies the water, you’re left drinking dark brown, bitter-tasting “bog tea.” 2. Why the Katadyn Hiker Pro FailsPleated Glass Fiber: Uses a folded, paper-like element. Fine peat silt wedges deep into those pleats almost immediately. Permanently Dead When Clogged: Unlike ceramic, glass fiber cannot be scrubbed or scraped. Once heavy peat fills the pleats, the cartridge is permanently ruined, leaving you with an expensive dead filter halfway through a trip. 3. Why the Grayl is a Great Filter, but a Financial Trap in BogsGreat Tech & Taste: The “fill-and-press” design is super convenient, purifies viruses, and its carbon element cleans up tannin taste well.Expensive Cartridges: Replacement filters run between £25.00 and £30.00 each.Bog Water Destroys Lifespan: While rated for roughly 150 to 250 liters (300–350 cycles) in clean water, fine peat silt and tannins choke Grayl’s electroadsorptive media rapidly. Because you cannot scrub or backflush a Grayl cartridge, press times quickly jump from 10 seconds to several minutes per press. Replacing £25–£30 cartridges every few bog trips gets brutally expensive. 4. Why the MSR MiniWorks EX is the Clear WinnerField-Scrubbable Ceramic (The Game Changer): Every filter clogs in bog water. The difference is that when the MiniWorks EX clogs, you simply unscrew the casing and scrub the dirty outer layer of ceramic with an abrasive pad. This removes the mud, exposes fresh ceramic, and restores 100% flow rate in 60 seconds for £0. Activated Carbon Core: It features an internal carbon core that strips out tannins, turning brown, bitter bog water back into clear, neutral-tasting drinking water.Bombproof Reliability: It’s heavier and slower to pump than modern squeeze/press filters, but its simple mechanical design and thick ceramic media can handle hundreds of liters of thick, gritty silt without failing or costing you extra money in replacements. Conclusion: Bog water clogs everything. The Katadyn gets permanently ruined, the Guardian’s fibers get blinded by tannins, and the Grayl becomes a money pit replacing £25–£30 cartridges when peat clogs them. The MSR MiniWorks EX lets you scrape off the peat mud, scrub it clean, and strip out the brown tannin taste repeatedly in the field.

   Reply

5. I have used Waterdrop gravity filter in two of my weekend backcouy trips now. It worked great when I collected dirty water form the middle of the lake than from the shore. It clogged on me the 2nd way of the trip. I just learned how to backwash it. Let’s see how it goes in the next trip.

   Reply